I talked very briefly in one of my previous posts about Michael Vick potentially being a decent fit for the Dolphins. There are a few teams out there that I think he could actually thrive, if he were to be traded. That all depends on him though.
Raiders:
Who is their QB right now? Aaron Brooks or Andrew Walter? Does it matter? Brooks hasn’t been the same since he had that tough luck injury in New Orleans, and I don’t think he will be able to bounce back in a starting role anytime soon. Walter is just awful. Just terrible. I have nothing good to say about him whatsoever.
So is this a good fit for Vick? It all depends what you have to give up to get him. The first overall pick? I wouldn’t. Randy Moss? Sort of makes sense if he wants out of there, but if he knew Vick was coming would that make him change his mind? If yes, I say keep him. If Lamont Jordan can bounce back and be as good as he was two years ago, this team has the makings of a halfway decent offense, but they need to look carefully at the Tight Ends out there and either draft a couple (ala the Patriots) or trade for a proven veteran. They have decent WRs in Doug Gabriel, Ronald Curry, and of course Randy Moss, but they need a smaller Deion Branch type of receiver. Someone smaller and quick that can get lost in traffic, especially with those big targets in Moss and Gabriel. Like I said, it all depends on what Oakland needs to give up to get him. If it’s minimal, I don’t see why the risk would be greater than the reward.
Philadelphia:
This might sound insane, but I’d be surprised if Jeff Garcia is back with the Eagles next year. Too many teams have a need for a great veteran QB and who wouldn’t want Garcia?? Detroit was stupid and passed on him, letting him jet to Philly, and Houston opted not to sign him and keep riding Carr until his wheels fell off.
That said, with Donovan McNabb coming back from a severe knee injury, the Eagles may sign Garcia to a two year deal, just for insurance purposes. If they don’t, would it make sense for them to go after Vick?
I think it could definitely be intriguing. Don’t get me wrong, I love McNabb, but he’s always McHurt, and you need other options (ie: Garcia) in case he misses another huge portion of a season. He was off to an MVP like season before he got hurt, which is incredibly aggravating for him and the Eagles fans. Garcia filled in quite nicely down the stretch though, so who knows.
Detroit:
This move really hinges on whether Mike Martz is staying put. The Lions have 3 good QBs on their roster in John Kitna, Josh Mcown, and the little known Dan Orlovsky from UConn, who was coincidentally drafted where I guessed he would be, but just not by the right team (I guessed the Patriots would snag him in the 6th round, but they traded that pick to…the Lions).
All of them are good QBs, but the MO for Kitna is the same: can throw up gaudy numbers on both sides of the ball (passing yards, completions, but always too many interceptions). Mcown lined up at WR during the last couple games last season and gave the Lions an intriguing threat. Orlovsky never sees any playing time except for preseason, even though I’ve heard that Mike Martz is in love with the kid, as he compares him favorably to Marc Bulger. Personally I think Orlovsky should play in NFL Europe this season, especially if they think he won’t have a legit shot at winning the starting job this year. It’s too draining really to play NFL Europe, then Training Camp, then a 16 game season for the NFL. Who knows though, maybe the Lions have bigger players for him than just Europe?
Detroit probably has a decent combination of talent at Wide Receiver and draft picks the Falcons could really sink their talons into. Having extended Mike Furrey’s deal, the Lions could deal Mike Williams and some picks to Hotlanta for Vick. Is this a deal they should make? I don’t think so, but then again, Matt Millen is the worst GM in the business, so he probably would if he could.
Houston:
I understand being faithful to a franchise Quarterback (please see Brett Favre in Green Bay, Kansas City putting Trent Green back into the starting lineup after Damon Huard helped them keep things going, etc.). But sometimes you have to know when to do something to spark said franchise QB’s competitive juices.
If a player thinks he has no danger of losing his job, he’ll do just enough to not lose it, and won’t go all out. That is the situation in Houston.
Charlie Casserly screwed up royally when he opted to draft Mario Williams over Reggie Bush, or even Vince Young. Young would have been a great fit because David Carr just hasn’t been able to get it done down in Houston. With him being a local kid too and graduating from the University of Texas, you’d instantly have an even bigger fan base. Drafting Williams is just dumb, as I outlined here for numerous reasons. The Texans should have spent some money on a proven DE before drafting Williams, because they could have had a legit franchise QB in Young or RB in Bush, both who surely would have filled the seats in Proliant Stadium.
The Texans could actually make up for the drafting blunder of last year by working a nice little package to get Vick. Since he never stays in the pocket for long anyways, it wouldn’t matter if he wants to take off running on every other play rather than going through his progressions and being able to stand in the pocket tall and make a good pass.
Cleveland:
Every Quarterback that goes to Cleveland seems destined to fail. Ever heard of Tim Couch? Do you think that Charlie Frye can lead the Browns to the playoffs?
Nope.
They have numerous pieces that fit perfectly on their team as far as defense goes, but a lot of the credit there lands on Romeo Crennel. He knows what he has defensively, what he needs, and he’s not afraid to shake things up a bit, which is why I think if they ever did trade for Vick, it would center around a pick or two and a defensive player or two as well, because he could replace a defensive player much easier than an offensive.
Would Vick thrive in Cleveland? Most likely not, but I can’t think of too many QBs that would at this point. Cleveland is a team that is kept in most games by it’s defense for half the game and then lose it because their offense doesn’t bail them out, at which point they give up 5 TDs in the second half.
Regardless whether or not Michael Vick goes anywhere, you can rest assured the Falcons will quietly shop him, especially after his recent headline making antics with a Poland Spring bottle and marijuana (read: bong). Coupled with flipping off the entire Falcon Faithful this season, it just doesn’t look like Vick is long for the Falcons. Then again, maybe owner Arthur Blank deems him untradeable. Who knows. It will be interesting seeing where he could land to say the least.